Earnings Manipulation: Techniques That Investors Must Watch Out For

As an experienced investor, one of my goals is to help others avoid common pitfalls in analyzing company financials. One such pitfall is falling for earnings manipulation. This practice is the art of making a company’s financial performance look better than it really is by using accounting tricks. While these tactics can be legal, they distort a company’s true financial health and make it harder for investors to assess the business accurately.

In this post, I’ll explain some of the most common techniques companies use to manipulate earnings, so you can be better equipped to spot red flags when analyzing potential investments.

1. Boosting Income Using One-Time or Unsustainable Activities

Some companies resort to temporary or one-off events to inflate their income, which can make their financials look stronger than they truly are.

• Boosting income using one-time events: A company may sell off a valuable asset, such as a building or subsidiary, and record the profit from this sale as regular income. This one-time windfall artificially inflates earnings for that period, misleading investors into thinking the business’s core operations are improving. These gains won’t be repeated, yet they make the earnings look inflated.
• Boosting income through misleading classifications: Some companies may reclassify regular operating expenses as non-operating or extraordinary. By moving expenses out of the operational side of the income statement, the company can make its core business seem more profitable than it really is. This is a deceptive tactic because the true cost of doing business is hidden.

2. Shifting Current Expenses to a Later Period

Delaying the recognition of expenses is a common way to manipulate earnings. By postponing expenses, a company can inflate its current profitability.

• Excessively capitalizing normal operating expenses: Companies may capitalize normal operating expenses, like maintenance or repairs, by recording them as long-term assets instead of expenses. By doing so, they spread the cost over multiple periods instead of taking the hit in the current one, artificially inflating profits in the short term.
• Amortizing costs too slowly: When a company amortizes expenses, it spreads the cost over multiple periods. By doing this too slowly (i.e., over too many years), the company reduces current expenses, boosting earnings in the short term.
• Failing to write down assets with impaired value: When an asset loses value, companies are supposed to write it down to reflect its reduced worth. Some companies fail to do this, keeping the impaired asset on their books at an inflated value, which avoids recognizing a loss in the current period.
• Failing to record expenses for uncollectible receivables and devalued investments: Companies may avoid writing off bad debts or investments, keeping the appearance of financial strength. By not recognizing these losses, they preserve earnings for the current period, but it’s a ticking time bomb when these losses eventually have to be recognized.

3. Employing Other Techniques to Hide Expenses or Losses

Some companies go to great lengths to hide expenses to maintain the appearance of profitability.

• Failing to record an expense at the appropriate amount from a current transaction: A company might delay or understate current expenses, such as payments to suppliers or interest expenses, to artificially boost current earnings.
• Recording inappropriately low expenses by using aggressive accounting assumptions: Companies may use overly optimistic assumptions about things like depreciation or warranties. These assumptions lead to unrealistically low expenses, inflating earnings for the period.
• Reducing expenses by releasing reserves from previous charges: If a company has set aside reserves for potential future liabilities (like legal settlements), it might release these reserves back into income once it’s determined that the liability won’t materialize. This boosts current earnings, but it’s essentially a bookkeeping trick, not an improvement in real business performance.

4. Shifting Current Income to a Later Period

Sometimes, companies manipulate earnings by delaying the recognition of income to future periods, smoothing out their performance over time.

• Creating reserves and releasing them into income in a later period: Companies may set up reserves (sometimes overly large) and then release them in future periods to smooth out earnings when performance is weak. This gives the illusion of consistent earnings growth.
• Smoothing income by improperly accounting for derivatives: Companies that deal with derivatives can use complex accounting to shift income between periods, smoothing out their earnings. By doing this, they give the impression of steady, predictable performance when the reality may be more volatile.
• Creating reserves in conjunction with an acquisition and releasing them into income in a later period: During an acquisition, a company might overestimate the liabilities of the acquired company and set up large reserves. Later, it releases those reserves into income, artificially boosting earnings when needed.
• Recording current-period sales in a later period: Companies may push sales into future periods by delaying the recognition of revenue. This tactic is often used when current-period sales are stronger than expected, and management wants to smooth out earnings over time.

5. Shifting Future Expenses to an Earlier Period

Sometimes, companies manipulate their earnings by accelerating the recognition of expenses, making future periods look better than they would otherwise.

• Improperly writing off assets in the current period to avoid expenses in a future period: A company may choose to take large write-offs in a single period, often referred to as a “big bath,” to clear out expenses. This inflates future profits by reducing future expenses artificially.
• Improperly recording charges to establish reserves used to reduce future expenses: In this scenario, companies overstate expenses in the current period by creating reserves that will later be used to offset future costs. This tactic is essentially the opposite of failing to write down bad assets: it front-loads the expenses so future earnings look better.

Conclusion

Get Deann Steyn’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Remember me for faster sign in

As investors, it’s critical to recognize the many ways companies manipulate earnings to make their financial performance look better than it is. These tactics, while sometimes legal, distort the reality of a business and can lead to bad investment decisions. By understanding these techniques, you can spot the red flags and dig deeper into a company’s financial statements to get a clearer picture of its true health. Stay vigilant, and always question when numbers seem too good to be true.

A Message from InsiderFinance

Thanks for being a part of our community! Before you go:

• 👏 Clap for the story and follow the author 👉
• 📰 View more content in the InsiderFinance Wire
• 📚 Take our FREE Masterclass
• 📈 Discover Powerful Trading Tools